Alhurra

Trump’s Gaza Plan: Big Hopes, Bigger Questions 

Joe Kawly

Share

Peace plans come and go. Few, however, arrive with such a chorus of endorsements that they raise both eyebrows and hopes.
Four days ago, at an unusually choreographed White House ceremony, President Donald Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu unveiled a 20-point roadmap aimed at ending the war in Gaza. The rollout was a political spectacle in itself: not only the United States and Israel, but also a surprising coalition of Arab and Muslim leaders stood behind a single document. The breadth of backing was unexpected. The deeper question, however, is whether this moment of consensus will translate into lasting peace, or prove just another pause before the storm.
To explore the stakes, Joe Kawly spoke exclusively with Robert Satloff, Executive Director of The Washington Institute and one of Washington’s most influential voices on Middle East policy. Satloff acknowledges the novelty of the endorsements but warns against mistaking symbolism for substance. “Without Hamas, it is doubtful this plan can move forward,” he says bluntly, pointing to the unavoidable obstacle that looms over any deal.

The 20-point document outlines a phased Israeli withdrawal accompanied by a security buffer zone, tentative steps toward recognizing a Palestinian state, and governance reforms tied to disarmament. It also hints at controversial roles for figures like former British Prime Minister Tony Blair, who has been floated as a possible mediator. Every detail has already sparked fierce debate, reflecting the delicate balance between political demands and security imperatives in a region where compromise is fragile.

What makes this plan stand out is not the specifics alone, but the urgency of its backing. After two years of devastating conflict and failed initiatives, this proposal has drawn international support at a rare scale. Yet Satloff offers a sober reminder: “Nothing succeeds like success.” In Gaza, he notes, success will be measured not by ceremonies or signatures but by lives saved, aid delivered, and violence halted. The true test will come not in the fanfare of its launch, but in whether the plan survives the silence of the days that follow.

Author

  • Joe Kawly is a veteran global affairs journalist with over two decades of frontline reporting across Washington, D.C. and the Middle East. A CNN Journalism Fellow and Georgetown University graduate, his work focuses on U.S. foreign policy, Arab world politics, and diplomacy. With deep regional insight and narrative clarity, Joe focuses on making complex global dynamics clear, human, and relevant.
RECOMMENDED